The differences between the commitments of the beef chain
The transition to more responsible beef production in the Amazon requires the full implementation of the commitments assumed in 2009 by several sectors.
There are two commitments in effect: the Terms of Adjustment of Conduct (TAC) signed by the meatpackers with the Public Prosecutor's Office (MPF) and the so-called Public Livestock Commitment, proposed by Greenpeace and entered into by the three leading beef companies (JBS, Marfrig and Minerva) also in 2009. TACs are extrajudicial agreements mediated by the MPF and the Public Livestock Commitment is a voluntary commitment aimed at zero deforestation.
The TACs aim to establish conditions and criteria for the purchase of cattle in the Amazon. The companies are jointly and severally committed to preventing the cattle of producers involved in environmental, land and social irregularities from being sold. The Public Commitment is very similar to the TAC (see Table 1); however, it includes the criterion of zero deforestation since it states that no deforestation can occur after 2009.
Table 1 - Similarities and differences in the commitments in effect in the Amazon
Legend: X = does not address
Y = addresses
| Criteria | Terms of Adjustment of Conduct for the state of Pará (TAC Pará) | Terms of Adjustment of Conduct for the Amazon (TAC Amazon) | Public Commitment |
| Cut-off date | 01/08/2008 | 22/07/2008 | 05/10/2009 |
| Zero deforestation | X | X | |
| Illegal deforestation | Y | Y | Y |
| Overlap with Indigenous Lands | Y | Y | Y |
| Overlap with Conservation Units | Y | Y | Y |
| Ibama's environmental embargo | Y | Y | Y |
| State environmental embargo (list) | X | X | |
| List of slave-like labour | Y | Y | Y |
| CAR | Y | Y | Y |
| Changes to the limits of CAR | X | X | X |
| Rural Environmental License (LAR) | Y | Y | Y |
| GTA | Y | Y | Y |
To learn more and understand how these criteria should be monitored, please visit the Information page and read the Cattle Supplier Monitoring Protocol.
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS IN THE BEEF VALUE CHAIN: SETTING THE BAR TO CREATE THE VOLUNTARY PROTOCOL FOR MONITORING CATTLE SUPPLIERS IN THE CERRADO REGION – Draft 1 for consultation – July, 2021
This study shows that most of the companies and non-governmental initiatives in this analysis have agreed not to convert the biome, however, there is a lack of alignment in the criteria and parameters used.
Monitoring slave labour is still a challenge in the country's value chains
The inclusion of social issues would be a great step forward in the monitoring of production chains in the country.
Technical Report: Analysis of Certification Systems for Heather Production
Document describes and analyses three certification programs applicable to leather: Brazilian Leather Sustainability Certification Program (CSCB), Leather Working Group (LWG), and Istituto di Certificazione della Qualità per l'Area Pelle (LWG, the Italian Quality Certification Institute for the Leather Sector). Beef on Track, December 2020.